Manchester United lose one option to replace Michael Carrick next season
The Red Devils are monitoring alternative candidates, although the current manager’s strong performances could convince the club to keep him
In just a matter of weeks, the atmosphere at Old Trafford has shifted from despair to genuine hope. Following the departure of Ruben Amorim, the club opted for an internal stop-gap, handing the reins to Michael Carrick. What initially looked like a temporary patch has turned into a tactical masterclass, leaving the board in an incredibly awkward—yet positive—position.
The Giant Slayer: Carrick’s Incredible Start
In just five matches at the helm, Carrick has transformed United’s season. His record of four wins and one draw has catapulted the team back into the Champions League conversation. However, it’s not just the points—it’s the scalps he has taken along the way.
OpponentResultSignificanceManchester CityWinLocal bragging rights & defensive masterclass.ArsenalWinTactical outclassing of a title contender.TottenhamWinRestored dominance over the "Big Six."
These results have done more than just help the standings; they have healed a squad that was emotionally shattered just a month ago.
The Tuchel Blow: England Closes the Door
Despite the "Carrick Surge," Sir Jim Ratcliffe and the INEOS leadership remain fixated on their original roadmap: hiring a world-class manager to lead a long-term structural project.
The primary target was Thomas Tuchel. The German’s resume—headlined by his Champions League, Club World Cup, and UEFA Super Cup triumphs with Chelsea—made him the dream candidate. The plan was to wait until late 2026 to negotiate. However, the Football Association (FA) just threw a wrench in those gears.
Official Update: The FA has announced a contract extension for Thomas Tuchel as England manager through 2028. With Euro 2028 as the strategic goal, Tuchel has publicly reaffirmed his absolute commitment to the Three Lions, effectively ending United’s pursuit.
Plan B: The New Shortlist
With Tuchel off the table, the United hierarchy is exploring modern, tactical alternatives that align with their vision of a "structural renewal."
- Enzo Maresca: The former Chelsea man is a top contender. His younger profile and cutting-edge tactical approach fit the INEOS mold.
- Xabi Alonso: Still highly coveted for his revolutionary work in the Bundesliga.
- Xavi Hernández: Viewed as a candidate who can implement a specific, dominant identity.
- Carlo Ancelotti: The "Grandmaster" option for immediate prestige and locker room management.
The Ultimate Dilemma
As Michael Carrick continues to rack up points and win over the Stretford End, the board faces a defining choice. Do they stick with the man who has already restored competitiveness and hope to the fans? Or do they gamble on a "big name" who might struggle to replicate Carrick's immediate chemistry with the current squad?
At Old Trafford, the "interim" tag is starting to feel very permanent.
