The Premier League legend who forgets about Haaland for an important reason

Jamie Carragher, former Liverpool captain, has sparked controversy by revealing his list of the 10 best strikers in Premier League history during the "Monday Night Football" program alongside Thierry Henry. The omission of current figures like Erling Haaland and the inclusion of Gareth Bale have generated an intense debate among fans and football experts in England.

Carragher explained that his selection criteria was based on "the impact the players have had in the Premier League," differentiating between "great goalscorers" and "wide forwards," a more common role in today's football. This distinction, however, has not convinced many, especially by leaving out Haaland, a relentless goalscorer who has broken records since arriving at Manchester City. The absence of Harry Kane, another historic Premier League goalscorer, has also been criticized.

Carragher's list, in descending order, is as follows:

1. Thierry Henry
2. Mo Salah
3. Cristiano Ronaldo
4. Eric Cantona
5. Didier Drogba
6. Wayne Rooney
7. Alan Shearer
8. Eden Hazard
9. Dennis Bergkamp
10. Gareth Bale

The inclusion of Gareth Bale in tenth place, ahead of Dennis Bergkamp, and the position of Alan Shearer, the Premier League's all-time top scorer, in seventh place, have been the most questioned decisions. Many believe that Shearer should occupy a much higher place on the list, given his impressive goalscoring record. The presence of Hazard, despite his talent, has also generated debate, considering that his performance in the Premier League was not consistently maintained throughout his career.

Carragher's justification for including Bale focuses on the impact the Welshman had during his time at Tottenham, where he dazzled with his speed, power, and goalscoring ability. However, many argue that his time in the Premier League was relatively short compared to other strikers who were left off the list.

The omission of Haaland, despite his short career in the Premier League, is considered surprising given his immediate impact and his ability to score goals at an impressive rate. Some argue that it is still too early to include him in a list of the best of all time, but others believe that his current performance justifies his inclusion.

In short, Carragher's list has generated great controversy and has opened a debate about the criteria for choosing the best strikers in the Premier League. The omission of Haaland and Kane, along with the inclusion of Bale and Shearer's position, have been the most controversial points of a list that will surely continue to be talked about.