The controversial decision Carlo Ancelotti made at Real Madrid before facing Pachuca

Real Madrid are on the verge of another title under Carlo Ancelotti’s management: the Intercontinental Cup against Pachuca. However, the lead-up to this important fixture has been overshadowed by a decision from the Italian manager that has generated significant debate among the Madrid faithful. The exclusion of Raúl Asensio from the starting eleven, yet again, and the inclusion of a central midfielder, Aurélien Tchouaméni, in his place, has sparked controversy and placed the manager’s choices under scrutiny.

The Context: An Asensio in Top Form

The controversy hasn’t arisen from thin air. Raúl Asensio had been showing impressive form in recent matches, with stand-out performances, goals, and assists that were establishing him as a key component in Real Madrid’s attack. His ability to create chances, his long-range shooting, and his understanding with his teammates made him a significant attacking threat. Therefore, Ancelotti’s decision to relegate him to the bench in a match of this magnitude is, for many, baffling.

The Gamble on Tchouaméni: A Tactical Masterstroke or a Strategic Blunder?

The inclusion of Tchouaméni, a defensive midfielder, in a position theoretically designated for an attacking player like Asensio, raises several questions. Ancelotti might be aiming to bolster the midfield, seeking greater control of the ball and defensive solidity against a Pachuca side that could present a physical game with quick transitions. However, this decision sacrifices the creativity and attacking potential that Asensio provides.

Some pundits suggest that Ancelotti might be opting for a more conservative approach, especially considering the importance of the game and the possibility of Pachuca setting up defensively. Tchouaméni’s presence could offer greater balance and prevent potential counter-attacks. Nevertheless, this strategy could be interpreted as a lack of faith in the team’s attacking capabilities and a renunciation of a more proactive style of play.

Fan and Press Reactions:

Ancelotti’s decision hasn’t gone unnoticed by either the fans or the press. Social media has been flooded with critical comments aimed at the manager, questioning his judgement and advocating for Asensio’s inclusion in the starting line-up. Many fans believe that the player’s exclusion is unfair and that his good form is being wasted.

The sports media has also picked up on this controversy, with articles and debates analysing the reasons behind Ancelotti’s decision. Some outlets have described the decision as “incomprehensible” and “a strategic error,” while others attempt to find a tactical justification for the gamble on Tchouaméni.

Possible Explanations for Ancelotti’s Decision:

Beyond the controversy, it’s important to consider some possible reasons that might have led Ancelotti to make this decision:

• Tactical Considerations: As mentioned previously, Ancelotti might be looking for greater balance in midfield and more defensive solidity. Tchouaméni’s presence could provide greater protection and prevent potential surprises.
• Squad Rotation and Management: Ancelotti might be aiming to manage the workload of his players, especially in a demanding season with multiple competitions. Including Tchouaméni could be a way of resting other players and keeping the squad fresh.
• Trust in Other Players: Ancelotti might have greater confidence in other players for this particular match, considering the opposition’s characteristics and the tactical approach.
• Injuries or Fatigue: Although no injury to Asensio has been reported, there might be some physical discomfort or fatigue that has influenced the manager’s decision.

The Impact on the Match and Asensio’s Future:

Ancelotti’s decision could have a significant impact on the course of the match. Asensio’s absence could reduce Real Madrid’s attacking potential, while Tchouaméni’s presence could provide greater defensive stability.

Furthermore, this situation could affect Asensio’s future at the club. If the player continues to be relegated to the bench despite his good performances, he might seek a move in the next transfer window in search of more playing time and a more prominent role.

Conclusion:

Carlo Ancelotti’s decision to leave out Raúl Asensio in the final against Pachuca has generated considerable controversy among fans and the press. While there might be tactical justifications, the exclusion of a player in such good form is difficult for many to understand. The outcome of the match and the explanation that Ancelotti offers after the game will be crucial in evaluating the wisdom or folly of this controversial decision.